So you say you only applied to schools within 2 hours from your partner, and that these did not have 'all stars' but it was OK since your partner was staying at his job for the next few years...
Then you say next year you could apply to more/better schools further away...so you want to live one year with your SO and then apply for more schools with better programs but further away, potentially going to live far away? Is this right?
Maybe you could defer for a year...get married, live with him, and get more experience. But if you apply again for better schools further away you have to face the possibility you will not live with him unless he moves with you...Can you spend 4-6 years in grad schools doing the long distance thing?