-
Posts
2,154 -
Joined
-
Last visited
-
Days Won
85
Reputation Activity
-
dr. t reacted to AP in 2022 Application Thread
This is unsolicited advise for those who received an offer.
First, I want to reiterate and heavily insist on what several of us veterans here try to convey periodically: there is more to a program than the imagined prestige of the university. Not all programs are fit for everyone, so as you get acceptances, research everything that tilts your needle: research funds, summer stipends, healthcare, teaching responsibilities, living costs, etc.
Secondly, I'm sure you are aware of the Harvard Anthropology Dept issue taking up much of Twitter this week (tl;dr: A prof in the dept was put from paid to unpaid leave because of the findings of a sexual harassment complaint. The problem is that big names in Anthro and outside of Anthro (especially historians) from Harvard and off-Harvard have closed ranks in two open letters, protecting their colleague). [I'm not characterizing Harvard or any department here, but I personally find it troublesome how tenured folks quickly closed ranks without having all the information, which neither have I].
To this end, I share a resource you might find useful, a database of sexual harassment complaints and their status: https://academic-sexual-misconduct-database.org/
I hope you find it useful.
-
dr. t got a reaction from psstein in 2022 Application Thread
Not many of those, no, and veterans get hiring priority in that kind of work. CCs are as nice or as terrible a place to work as any other job, and there's not an abundance of CC positions around, either.
The key is to distill your skillset and then craft an argument that it applies. For example, I'm trained as a historian to work with linguistic nuance and an exceptionally close reading of texts while maintaining a mastery over the broader picture on both a historical and theoretical level; I work as an editor-in-chief.
(My IRL identity, btw is not a secret on this forum, though I usually don't advertise it.)
-
dr. t got a reaction from ashwel11 in 2022 Application Thread
The poster there is a bit of an idiot and not the best historian I've come across. They (and other "experts") posted enough wrong information that I got frustrated and then banned from that sub for calling them out on it... almost a decade ago now? There's a lot of hyperbole, and they don't consider that, if you apply to the right program, you can spend 5-7 years doing what you love with comp'd trips to Europe, as I did, which isn't a bad thing.
But there is a kernel of truth there: there are no academic jobs, there will not be academic jobs, you will not get an academic job, and you are not special. The quality of your dissertation, number of publications, or prestige of your institution will not change that.
-
dr. t got a reaction from TheWitWitch in 2022 Application Thread
Not many of those, no, and veterans get hiring priority in that kind of work. CCs are as nice or as terrible a place to work as any other job, and there's not an abundance of CC positions around, either.
The key is to distill your skillset and then craft an argument that it applies. For example, I'm trained as a historian to work with linguistic nuance and an exceptionally close reading of texts while maintaining a mastery over the broader picture on both a historical and theoretical level; I work as an editor-in-chief.
(My IRL identity, btw is not a secret on this forum, though I usually don't advertise it.)
-
dr. t got a reaction from TagRendar in 2022 Application Thread
Not many of those, no, and veterans get hiring priority in that kind of work. CCs are as nice or as terrible a place to work as any other job, and there's not an abundance of CC positions around, either.
The key is to distill your skillset and then craft an argument that it applies. For example, I'm trained as a historian to work with linguistic nuance and an exceptionally close reading of texts while maintaining a mastery over the broader picture on both a historical and theoretical level; I work as an editor-in-chief.
(My IRL identity, btw is not a secret on this forum, though I usually don't advertise it.)
-
dr. t got a reaction from NotAlice in 2022 Application Thread
The poster there is a bit of an idiot and not the best historian I've come across. They (and other "experts") posted enough wrong information that I got frustrated and then banned from that sub for calling them out on it... almost a decade ago now? There's a lot of hyperbole, and they don't consider that, if you apply to the right program, you can spend 5-7 years doing what you love with comp'd trips to Europe, as I did, which isn't a bad thing.
But there is a kernel of truth there: there are no academic jobs, there will not be academic jobs, you will not get an academic job, and you are not special. The quality of your dissertation, number of publications, or prestige of your institution will not change that.
-
dr. t got a reaction from psstein in 2022 Application Thread
The poster there is a bit of an idiot and not the best historian I've come across. They (and other "experts") posted enough wrong information that I got frustrated and then banned from that sub for calling them out on it... almost a decade ago now? There's a lot of hyperbole, and they don't consider that, if you apply to the right program, you can spend 5-7 years doing what you love with comp'd trips to Europe, as I did, which isn't a bad thing.
But there is a kernel of truth there: there are no academic jobs, there will not be academic jobs, you will not get an academic job, and you are not special. The quality of your dissertation, number of publications, or prestige of your institution will not change that.
-
dr. t got a reaction from QuarantineQuail in 2022 Application Thread
The poster there is a bit of an idiot and not the best historian I've come across. They (and other "experts") posted enough wrong information that I got frustrated and then banned from that sub for calling them out on it... almost a decade ago now? There's a lot of hyperbole, and they don't consider that, if you apply to the right program, you can spend 5-7 years doing what you love with comp'd trips to Europe, as I did, which isn't a bad thing.
But there is a kernel of truth there: there are no academic jobs, there will not be academic jobs, you will not get an academic job, and you are not special. The quality of your dissertation, number of publications, or prestige of your institution will not change that.
-
dr. t got a reaction from TheGradCocaCola in 2022 Application Thread
The poster there is a bit of an idiot and not the best historian I've come across. They (and other "experts") posted enough wrong information that I got frustrated and then banned from that sub for calling them out on it... almost a decade ago now? There's a lot of hyperbole, and they don't consider that, if you apply to the right program, you can spend 5-7 years doing what you love with comp'd trips to Europe, as I did, which isn't a bad thing.
But there is a kernel of truth there: there are no academic jobs, there will not be academic jobs, you will not get an academic job, and you are not special. The quality of your dissertation, number of publications, or prestige of your institution will not change that.
-
dr. t got a reaction from MDP in 2022 Creative Writing MFA Applicants Forum
Hi All,
This is getting quite tedious.
The report feature is for actual spam, egregious personal insults, threats, and the like. It is not for posts with which you disagree, or which say things (true or not) which you are uninterested in hearing. You have a downvote button for that, and your own ability not to engage.
Continued abuse of the reporting feature in the attempt to silence those with which you disagree, particularly under the flimsy and transparent guise of concern for the community, will, however, be subject to moderation.
-T
-
dr. t got a reaction from TagRendar in 2022 Application Thread
Adam (I assume it was Adam) is one of the better humans I've encountered in academia.
-
dr. t got a reaction from MatildaMedievalist in 2022 Application Thread
Adam (I assume it was Adam) is one of the better humans I've encountered in academia.
-
dr. t got a reaction from Mad Scientist Malfrost in 2022 Application Thread
As those of you with offers contemplate where (or if) to go, this is some food for thought:
https://www.historians.org/publications-and-directories/perspectives-on-history/december-2021/hustling-to-get-by-side-jobs-in-graduate-school
-
-
dr. t got a reaction from psstein in 2022 Application Thread
This is not a "my life sucks" competition, but I do want to caution that building coping strategies for this sort of stress will be super important going forwards. There's going to be a lot of it. Striking out on the job market (though I'm employed now!) last year gave me a literal midlife crisis at 35 this past summer, for example.
-
-
-
dr. t reacted to AP in 2022 Application Thread
This. is. crucial.
Not only for the job market, but for everything grad school related. It is those coping mechanisms that you develop since this moment during admissions that will help you down the road. Needless to say, we are all running on fumes of coping with the pandemic and all...
PS @dr. telkanuru I read your article!
-
dr. t got a reaction from TagRendar in 2022 Application Thread
This is not a "my life sucks" competition, but I do want to caution that building coping strategies for this sort of stress will be super important going forwards. There's going to be a lot of it. Striking out on the job market (though I'm employed now!) last year gave me a literal midlife crisis at 35 this past summer, for example.
-
dr. t got a reaction from Mile6 in 2022 Application Thread
This is not a "my life sucks" competition, but I do want to caution that building coping strategies for this sort of stress will be super important going forwards. There's going to be a lot of it. Striking out on the job market (though I'm employed now!) last year gave me a literal midlife crisis at 35 this past summer, for example.
-
-
dr. t got a reaction from TagRendar in 'Don't get a phd in history' - Does this apply to the UK?
No, the UK is worse. and this is not what a PhD in history will train you to do.
-
dr. t got a reaction from Prophecies in 'Don't get a phd in history' - Does this apply to the UK?
You're looking for maybe a public history degree, but really nothing.
-
dr. t got a reaction from EM51413 in 2022 Applicants
Do you want to be a university professor? Otherwise, no.
-
dr. t got a reaction from CoffeeCatsCorgis in 2022 Application Thread
I agree. Wait and drink heavily.