Hope I'm not too late to the game.
I've been agonizing over SIPA vs SAIS ever since decisions came out, as both have lots to offer. Some background: I'll likely explore government/policy positions in Washington and private sector/policy jobs in Japan, where I've lived the past six years. My longtime goal has been to join the Foreign Service, but I'm hesitant to commit to government, especially with the ongoing hiring slump.
My thinking so far on each school's merits:
SIPA:
- Offering $$
- Possible dual degree with University of Tokyo, which has dirt-cheap tuition and sets me up for Japan jobs
- Strong global brand
That said, I got weird vibes from a reception I attended in Tokyo recently. The one American I talked to didn't exactly gush about his experience, claiming the school's culture is highly transactional, and that students are most interested in whether you're a useful future contact. However, I don't want to make sweeping judgments based on a handful of interactions.
I also wonder if the dual degree would severely handicap my U.S. job search.
SAIS:
- In Washington
- Very impressed with the reception I attended. Everyone was incredibly friendly and professional, and I felt like they were the kind of people I want to be around
- The required international economics concentration helps with private sector jobs
On the other hand, I didn't receive funding from SAIS, which was a huge letdown. I think I'd enjoy SAIS more, but SIPA offers more financial upside.
At this point, I thin my decision hinges on the importance of location. If living in DC gives me a clear advantage with jobs, that might push me toward SAIS. But if location isn't THAT crucial (NY isn't far away, and SIPA has a strong alumni network), I'd be more inclined to pick SIPA.
Any thoughts--especially on the the importance of location and each school's culture--would be super helpful. Congrats to all and best of luck with your decisions!