"A 4.0 undergrad GPA? Ooh-la-la! Oh wait, it's from Stupid Idiots R Us University. Getting a 4.0 there is like managing not to poop yourself!"
"But oh, look, she did interesting work with a prestigious foreign university!"
"Yeah, but she's never been published. If her work there were so great, she would've gotten something publishable out of it. And look, her GRE scores are just okay. They'd probably fly at Stupid Idiots R Us University, but not HERE where we're GOOD AT STUFF."
"Well, her recommenders seem to love her! But... I've never heard of any of them. Are they really professors, or just her uncles?"
"And her SOP is just paranoid ramblings. Did she even edit this? Is this a Livejournal entry or something? Plus, she thinks that living in a foreign country is even worth mentioning! It has nothing to do with her field of study! And she jumped majors like the Fonz jumps sharks! Plus, she studied three languages, but she's not good at ANY of them! We need someone more focused than this!"
"And look, her research interests don't REALLY match up with those of anyone working here. Why did she even apply here? Does she even know who we are? Does she even know who SHE is? Are we all just figments of her imagination, tormenting her in a waking nightmare?"
"Hmm. Let's just put her at the bottom of the 'waitlist' pile and not tell her. If by some horrible twist of fate we actually accept her, we won't give her any funding. We certainly don't want her teaching impressionable undergrads or messing up anybody's research, either."