Jump to content

What do we know? A gathering of data on various programs.


Recommended Posts

Just returned from the Notre Dame recruitment weekend. Seemed like a great place(at least in IR/Security Studies). Faculty and Students seem really collegial ( suggested this is the case because there is plenty of funding for everyone so there is no competition between students.) Seemed really interested in the students work and willing to get them the training they need whether at Notre Dame or sending them to various other institutes to get the methods training the may need for their questions. Also seem to be adding new faculty which is always a good sign of the program growing.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

So Rochester's great. Department's really serious about training grad students, and a lot of really good people self-select into the program (a number of people had turned down offers from CHYMPS departments to go). Very close knit group of grad students. Kind of wish they had been less good so my decision would be easier. It's obviously an idiosyncratic place, but if you know you want to do formal theory or methods heavy work, I think they stack up well against any department.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

They are bringing alot of great people in recently, which is awesome. Luckily for you and for me, it seems that there is beginning to be a revival of security studies it seems at least after a lull for a decade that I've heard my advisors lament about.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I visited Rochester and Ohio State in the past week and I want to study formal, methods, and American so take this with a grain of salt.

Rochester: They really have a close knit group of people. The professors and grad students all seem to get along. The grad students all take the formal and methods sequence so the students at Rochester are generally great at math. This can be a great thing. The classes are notoriously hard and a professor of mine from the econ department at Rochester considers the program the hardest political science program in the world. Having students who can work together and aid each other through that kind of hell can be a huge asset. Also, the program kind of goes all-out when it comes to recruitment.

Ohio State: As someone else posted, the department is great - in IR. However, they are really suffering in American and Methods. They lost Luke Keele, Craig Volden, and Alan Weisman in the last year. They are hedging all bets on their incoming hires: a guy from Stanford GSB and one from UCSD. Their formal sequence is nearly non-existent. When it comes to their formal sequence, there are maybe two students. William Minozzi is a great guy and I think he will change how we look at formal theory in political science, Jan Box-Steffensmeier is great and is renowned in her studies in time series analysis, the department wants to hire more networks people in the future but the program is really in a rebuilding stage.

Edited by Alptitude
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I know Harvard visit is going on right now, so just wondering if anyone would like to share some scoop and thoughts? I am really sad I can't go. :(

not quite. it starts on wednesday. there was some general GSAS thing that happened over the weekend but that seemed mostly about housing and whatnot. I'll be at the department one. i can let you know how it went when i get back

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2 weeks later...
  • 2 weeks later...
  • 1 year later...
  • 3 weeks later...

Any info about IR and/or Political Theory at Ohio State?

I promise I will provide info once I am done visiting all schools. However, take any info you get from gradcafe with a grain of salt, since we all have different priorities/research interests. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 11 months later...

Currently at a Top10 program:

 

(1) Theory job market still sucks. If you want a job in theory, Yale/Chicago are still probably your best bet

 

(2) For whatever reason, a lot of people last year really did not care for Princeton's visit days. No one doubts it is a good dept, but there were a lot of stories of profs and current grad students either not meshing well with admits, or in some cases failing to call them, etc., as scheduled. Unclear if this was a fluke or something to be concerned about going forward, but I personally know of three folks who turned down Princeton specifically because of the people. 

 

(3) The nation's best econ dept is at Stanford University. The second best econ dept is Stanford Political Science.

 

(4) From talking to friends at other T1 schools, Yale seems to have the reputation for having the most collegial faculty/also being the dept that won't flip out if you pursue something outside of academia. Have a friend at Stanford who said he would have picked Yale "hands down" if he were only choosing based on the people. 

 

(5) Yale killed it on the job market this year and also did very well last year. For all the talk about faculty exits, this doesn't seem to be impacting their placement too much

 

(6) Harvard continues to kill the job market as well. Seems to have had the best placement (along with Yale) the past 2-3 years. Stanford seems to have hit a bit of a rough patch, unclear why or how long it will last (it's Stanford, so probably not for long)

 

(7) Cornell and UNC have made some great tandem hires. Been pretty impressed with who comes out of Cornell as well. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

There was a bit of the disorganization alluded to above, I had a one on one meeting with a faculty member who just completely forgot about it and wasn't there. That said, the department seems across the board great, particularly if you're an Americanist with an interest in institutions (especially anything with law or the judiciary). The students seemed to not have too much of a social life outside of coursework unless they lived in New York or Philly (not surprising given that it's Princeton, NJ), though a sizeable portion of those in the dissertation stage did live in one of those two cities. If you have any more specific questions, feel free to PM me.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

There was a bit of the disorganization alluded to above, I had a one on one meeting with a faculty member who just completely forgot about it and wasn't there. That said, the department seems across the board great, particularly if you're an Americanist with an interest in institutions (especially anything with law or the judiciary). The students seemed to not have too much of a social life outside of coursework unless they lived in New York or Philly (not surprising given that it's Princeton, NJ), though a sizeable portion of those in the dissertation stage did live in one of those two cities. If you have any more specific questions, feel free to PM me.

 

Thanks for this! I'll PM you real soon.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

This website uses cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website. See our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use