Jump to content

TakeMyCoffeeBlack

Members
  • Posts

    825
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    11

Posts posted by TakeMyCoffeeBlack

  1. It seems like Northwestern only sent out acceptances for Theory and IR last week. I expect the acceptances for American and Comparative to come out anytime now..

     

    There may be some IR to come yet, too (not IR myself). It looked like the IR ones were also theory. I guess it would make sense for them to notify their theory people first, given their reputation for theory.

     

    Who wants to harass the department secretary? ;)

  2. I realize that. However, wouldn't they have just admitted less students this year then, if they were aiming for less people. Since they were not sure about the outcome of the hiring thing when they wrote this document, they must have written it before making decisions (the MR thing has been clear since August...). Do we know who the GT offer went out to, BTW?

     

    Yes, I'd imagine a smaller acceptance pool, maybe a larger WL pool, too.

  3. Thanks for taking one for the team, and trying it!

     

    Those that read it: Isn't it fishy that they already have enrollment figures for 2014? Or is that 2013? That would mean that they accepted a lot less this year?

     

    They have years of statistics to make yield predictions. They indicate a goal class size, not an actual one, for what it's worth.

  4. Some reading for those who haven't gotten much results. I've said before and I'll say it again. There are many many structural reasons why people don't get into grad school, and a lot of it has nothing to do with you. Also, many people in academia are not smart or bright or thinkers. Just because you haven't gotten in anywhere does not mean you aren't all of those things. :)

     

    http://www.gradientlair.com/post/64895770239/no-phd-for-me-moving-on-with-life

     

    I agree with you 100%. But then she starts in all valid places, and draws the oddest conclusions... It's not even clear she (or the people in the comments) understand what academia is, other than a title to throw before your name.

  5. Well, they're more or less a top 20 (this will fluctuate from ranking to ranking, of course), so unless you're considering a top 5 against it, I'd say that the ranking isn't something to be too concerned about. I'd look into: how well do I fit into the program? Do the professors seem nice? How is their placement in general? What about their placement in my sub-field/regional/theoretical interests? It's hard to generalize these things, but I'd say that Northwestern competes with the best of them. Rankings are, in my opinion, "soft" - that is, they're based on reputation, which can change from year to year and polled person to polled person. So they may fluctuate between 15 and 25, but they're not going to be moving between 15 and 45 (at least not anytime soon).

  6. This thread is nothing new to the Gradcafe crew, and who cares if the only purpose it serves is to "mollify" those on a wait list? If nothing else, it provides more information than is otherwise available. And though you're certainly right, James, that the wait list is a backup to the regular acceptance:yield ratio, this doesn't meant that others won't find the information useful. 

  7. has anybody yet claimed the handful of georgetown acceptances from yesterday? field of study, who called, etc?

     

    this is uncharacteristically early for georgetown, but as we learned today from princeton... history doesn't mean much haha

     

    Gtown (and ND, for that matter) seems to do a scattered admit pattern. Don't read into it too much.

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

This website uses cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website. See our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use