I chose Penn for several reasons: 1 year length versus 2 years (I've been out of school for 3, so going back for another 2 yrs would just be painful lol), the fact it's focused on higher education administration and not just student affairs (it has given me more of a broader over view of how higher education works and not so narrowly focused on one area of higher education), the diversity of the work faculty are doing and the student body are real (you see it and feel it, it's not just a talking point in an admissions brochure), the fact the people are easy going within Penn and Philly. I was struck by how laid back the atmosphere felt for an Ivy League, and the campus was unique because its in a urban setting yet has a collegial feel to it.
It was difficult to make my final decision because I was offered full rides, but I'm glad I chose this program. It can be a little over whelming to take on 5 classes and a GA (graduate assistantship) but as long as you organize and time manage yourself, you'll be fine. Trust me, everyone gets the hang of it after a month or so. Your professors and GA's are also aware of how much you have on your plate, so they're understanding. There's also the cohort to lean on and drink with to help you through it lol (which is a perk of having a cohort). About 90% of the previous cohort is employed. The rest have chosen to travel or not work out of personal choice, so I wouldnt worry too much. Currently my cohort is getting into the job search gear, so I cant give you many facts yet. One person has already gotten a job because an opening happened in her current GA. So you never know. I think you just need to look at what you value and prioritze that. How much experience do you have in higher education? What do you want out of the program? If you're searching for a more slow paced program where you can focus on theory and research then perhaps 2 years would be best. We have people in the cohort that came straight out of undergrad as well as people who are shifting careers, so there isn't a typical "student". You just really need to have a clue of what you might want to get out of the program and graduate school in general. I hope this long winded answer helps lol. If not, feel free to message me any other questions.