I’m applying to a mix of Ph.D. programs, about half of which are in Philosophy and the rest are in English/Literature. I imagine these programs will likely emphasize the Analytical Writing score more than other sections of the GRE, even though they will also expect a very good Verbal score.
I took the GRE 4 years ago before applying to Master’s programs and received 161V/149Q/4.5AW.
After retaking the GRE last month, I received 159V/147Q/5.5AW. (I'm quite devastated that a month of studying didn't improve my V & Q scores.)
I am tempted to submit the newest scores, as they will have a recent date and will demonstrate, along with my Writing Sample, the strength of my writing skills. However, I would be devastated if rejected from programs because the Verbal score from that retake is below 85th percentile.
Which scores would you suggest I submit? Would it make sense in my case to submit both scores, or do you think that might hinder my chances?
Thank you in advance for any help you can provide.