i will have my MA in may, my subject scores are still dismal, i'm using the same pretty good (almost 1400 combined) GRE scores, i have a clearly defined research topic/SOP, teaching experience, 5 conferences including an international one, i am responsible for coordinating a speaker on campus and i feel a hell of a lot better about myself than i did in my application round 2 years ago. how far will this get me? it remains to be seen...
that being said, a friend from my MA program last year got into 3 or so schools- 1 top 25, 1 top 40 and waitlisted at one top 20.
it's a crapshoot, dear friends.