MSW_2021
-
Posts
53 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Posts posted by MSW_2021
-
-
12 hours ago, angieeee said:
Hi guys. I need help on deciding between NYU and Columbia. I have been thinking about it for a month. NYU offers 30k in scholarship and no aid from Columbia. For anyone that chose between the 2 schools, why did you chose NYU/Columbia?
Have you paid your deposit for either schools yet? I chose NYU because their program is clinically focused and it was a bit cheaper. Columbia actually gave me more scholarship but the cost would've still been more than NYU. I would go with NYU since they offered you 30k. Both schools have similar field placements and curriculum. The biggest difference is Columbia offers tracks. Try talking to some current students/alums from both schools!
-
On 4/26/2021 at 10:10 AM, Msw246 said:
Yes, I want to say around 12-14 days. There is no deposit which is nice. You just have to submit your SIR. I am unsure about class registration, but I would imagine that we will receive our registration date sometime this summer. Our Fall quarter classes are the same for first-year students.
Hi! I've decided to attend UCLA and I messaged you with a few questions!
-
On 4/22/2021 at 7:35 PM, Msw246 said:
It took just under two weeks to receive the survey. I would imagine you have to accept their offer for admission, and then you would receive the survey and emails with more information.
I'm still going back and forth between NYU and UCLA but I think I'm leaning more towards UCLA since I'm from CA and it just makes more sense financially. Sorry for all the questions, so you received the field placement survey 2 weeks after you submitted your deposit? Do you know when class registration begins? Thank you!
-
14 minutes ago, Msw246 said:
Sorry, I just saw this message. I just filled out my survey for year one field placement, and they request in-depth answers to several personal statement questions regarding experiences we have had that will prepare us for field placement. Yes, a car is necessary! Another question they ask where we might be living to try and place us nearby for our field placement, but I am under the impression the likelihood is at least a 45-minute commute to our field placement. Yes, we do have to interview for our year two placement. Our second-year placement is for our specialization, allowing us an opportunity to get hands-on tying into our second-year coursework focusing on our specialty. I believe our first-year placement is trying to make us uncomfortable in a setting we are unfamiliar with, forcing us to become more versatile.
Also, they begin placing us immediately. It is on a first-come, first-serve basis. I submitted my survey yesterday, hoping I can get a solid placement!
I have not gotten that survey yet because I just got off the waitlist and I haven't sent in my SIR yet. How long did it take for them to send you the field placement survey?
-
10 minutes ago, DSWHopeful2021 said:
There won’t be repercussions. You have to do what’s in your best interest. They don’t keep a list or anything. They probably don’t even track it. They will get your deposit and easily backfill your spot from the wait list.
Should I tell them I'll be attending another school and go into detail why or just say that my circumstances have changed?
-
On 4/18/2021 at 1:26 AM, DSWHopeful2021 said:
Don’t worry about them. Higher education is a business - especially professional degree programs - and they’re used to it. I guarantee you they will have someone to fill your spot. If this were a PhD program, it would be a little different as far as politics and possibly burning bridges.... MSW level - don’t sweat it. When making your list of the pros and cons of each program - don’t give any weight to that aspect.
I think there's a big chance I'll be attending UCLA instead. Do you think NYU will be ok with that? I'm really worried about any possible repercussions.
-
1 hour ago, fafsaavoidant said:
Chiming in to cosign what has already been said. Thousands of dollars is a valid reason to change your mind about anything. Just be respectful and understanding, and it'll be fine. Telling them ASAP might even create space for someone who really wants to be at NYU and was waitlisted! Good luck, and congratulations on being able to choose between two great options!
Should I go into details and tell them which school I'll be attending or keep it short and just mention that my circumstances have changed with finances being the main reason?
-
5 hours ago, fafsaavoidant said:
All you can do is be honest, and give them as much heads up as you can. "I previously made a deposit, however circumstances have changed," isn't an awful way to start. Be apologetic, don't burn bridges, and let them know why! Perhaps you got a bigger scholarship somewhere else, or there's a family-related reason to stay closer to home.
Just remember, you're committing a lot of time and money, and you're the only one who will truly have to live with your decision. Schools are great, but they're also businesses run by real people. They'll get it. And you won't be the only one to do this, either.
...just don't expect to get that deposit back. You might. But also you definitely might not.
I know I won't be getting my deposit back and I'm fine with that. I committed to NYU and filled out the field placement form as well but I'm thinking of switching to UCLA (I was originally waitlisted but now offered a spot). Do you think I'll be burning bridges by telling NYU that I won't be attending anymore? One of the main reasons is cost tbh since I'm from CA and UCLA would be significantly cheaper. I didn't expect to get off the waitlist at all. I doubt I'll apply to NYU in the future but I just feel kind of bad.
-
Hey everyone! Has anyone paid their deposit and committed to a school and then changed their mind? How did you go about informing the other school that you're no longer attending?
-
On 4/18/2021 at 3:54 PM, Msw246 said:
It was my top academic choice by far-thinking it would be a long shot for me to be accepted, but here I am. I am a CA resident and only applied to CA schools due to the costs of out-of-state tuition. The affordability of CA schools and the expected salary of a social worker make it a hard sell to pursue an MSW degree out of state.
Hey! I was wondering if you knew anything about UCLA's field placement process? I attended one of their info sessions earlier on and also did some research. On their website, it says having a car is necessary for travel, do you know if that's mandatory? It seems like there's a interview process for 2nd year placements, do you know if we're guaranteed placements? I've been wanting to talk to a UCLA MSW student or alum but they don't seem to have anything on the website that connects you to one.
-
8 minutes ago, DSWHopeful2021 said:
I totally get that. Is school going to be in person this fall at NYU? I would also factor in Covid.
NYU mentioned that they're planning for in-person or hybrid but aren't 100% sure yet. UCLA's email mentions they expect to return to more in-person learning as well and we'll be updated. I think it's still up in the air for most schools. I have until the 30th to respond to UCLA so I'll think about it a bit more. I'm also not sure how I'll go about telling NYU that I won't be attending if I eventually change my mind and go with UCLA since I've already paid the deposit and even turned in my field placement form.
-
5 minutes ago, DSWHopeful2021 said:
UCLA is going to be about 36K for tuition and NYU looks to be about 106K tuition. Neither includes cost of living. Even with a 30K scholarship, NYU is 2x as expensive as UCLA. Again, depends on your financial situation.... but crushing student loan debt should be avoided if at all possible. Further, you could have access to stipends at UCLA in return for working with a CA-based agency (DCFS, DMH)... this would mean - essentially - a guaranteed job at graduation with an agency that pays pretty well and provides clinical supervision. UCLA is also pretty close to the West LA VA, another great agency to intern/work with.
I wouldn't say I'm in a position where I don't have to take out any loans and is completely without financial worries. I will have to take out some loans (regardless of the school) but most likely won't be the full tuition amount. I also don't have any undergraduate debt so I'm ok with taking out some loans. UCLA is definitely more affordable since I'm a CA resident. I think deep down my heart says NYU because I love NY and it has always been a dream of mine to live there so I feel like this is my chance. I've also done a lot of research on NYU and talked to MSW students there and I feel like their program really aligns with what I want to do. At the same time, UCLA is a great school and I'll probably have better connections for CA jobs.
- DSWstudentTSSW and sonalikm
-
1
-
1
-
48 minutes ago, Msw246 said:
Hey, I am attending UCLA, and this past Monday, I attended a "funding your education discussion." They send out a provisional financial aid letter that does not include any scholarships or aid. The advisor disclosed that aid and scholarships are decided on a "need-based aid" format. Meaning they determine how much aid we qualify for and disburse it during the fall, winter, and spring semester (for my understanding). So it is kind of a roll of the dice, hoping we receive as much as possible, but it is reassuring knowing we will receive aid. They also provide information on where we can go in search of scholarships and potential work-study options. I hope this helped, and most of all, congratulations.
Thanks for all the info! Was UCLA your top choice? I was so set on going to NYU and even paid my $300 deposit because I didn't expect to get off UCLA's waitlist. I'm a CA resident so attending UCLA would be a bit more affordable tuition wise but NYU also gave me 15k scholarship per year.
-
2 hours ago, DSWHopeful2021 said:
Are you a CA resident?
Yes, I'm a CA resident! I'm kind of debating my decision now about NYU.
-
-
4 hours ago, Ward said:
Hello hello,
I committed to NYU a couple of weeks back (although I'm still waiting on Columbia, even tho recent posts above make me think that they're response wouldn't be worth it in the least bit). Anything specific you were hoping someone who committed would have insight on?
I just committed to NYU yesterday! I decided to go with NYU over Columbia. I was wondering whether you submitted your field placement form for NYU yet? I haven't been able to because it says the website is down for maintenance?
-
Has anyone here committed to NYU?
-
1 minute ago, annadreams said:
Got it - yeah, that's the impression I have, too - more policy, and it seems many people come in interested in the dual MSW/MPH path that they offer. When someone asks, "what are the most clinically focused MSW programs?" I don't think Columbia is typically brought up; though that is not to say well-trained clinicians aren't coming out of Columbia's MSW program - of course there are. I have a vague impression that their counseling psych program at Teachers College may have the bigger draw for future therapists than the MSW program, but I could be wrong on that.
I have found the most clarity about the differentiating aspects between programs from talking to current students directly. I encourage you to reach out to NYU if they haven't already paired you with someone; I'm sure Columbia has a similar way to get you in touch with their students, or perhaps will have some admitted students event for facilitating such discussions. You could very well end up talking to someone who was recently making this same exact decision. And maybe see if there could be a way to sit in on virtual classes; I am doing that soon for USC.
I am most likely going to NYU, but I'm still deciding! If I get into Hunter (which is no guarantee, especially coming in as a career-changer), I would have a stark debt comparison to consider. Though I am still glad that I applied to the CA programs, I am starting to feel that they both make a bit less sense for my long term plans...
I did get paired up with a NYU Silver Champion! She had positive feedback for NYU and was deciding between USC or NYU. I'm from CA Bay Area and I always wanted to live in NY. I actually got into USC as well. I talked to a USC student and admissions counselor and after doing more research, felt like it wasn't the best fit for me. They also gave me the least aid so I told them I won't be attending a few days ago.
-
I got a rejection email from SFSU as well. Good luck to everyone else!
- fiofarrell17, GemGirl and Jacquesters
-
3
-
2 hours ago, annadreams said:
I posted a response to this same question from another user a little while back - page 29 of this thread, or check my profile to find it! The short version: I recently talked to someone who picked NYU over Columbia. She said it was because NYU seemed more clinically focused overall, and that it has a broader and/or more psychodynamic orientation (vs. CBT). That's one person's opinion (and she is a person who wants to work as a therapist as an LCSW in private practice). This general impression has been echoed by others who I have talked with in the field.
(It could be worth noting that I personally decided not to apply to Columbia, so I have likely not investigated the "pros" of their program deep enough, or to the same degree of research as how I am evaluating NYU's program.)
I'm not sure what your personal criteria or wishes are for deciding on the programs, or also what it is that you are more broadly hoping to get from the MSW degree and experience of study. With more info, others may be able to steer you or give you more tailored insights. Good luck in your decision, and congrats on all your acceptances!
I also heard NYU is more clinically focused which is why I'm drawn to it. I know Columbia also has a clinical concentration but it seems they're more known for macro and policy. I feel like I might get better clinical training at NYU. Are you going to NYU?
-
I was accepted into both NYU and Columbia and having a hard time deciding where to attend. Anyone here in the same situation and has already committed to either of the schools? If so, why did you pick one over the other?
-
Has anyone tried appealing for more scholarship from NYU? What is the process like?
-
Has anyone gotten their financial aid package from Columbia? I got mine today and they're giving 20k per year in scholarship. Does anyone know the max amount of scholarship they give out?
-
Finally heard back from Columbia today! I got in! (Applied 12/1)
- Gradguy11218, Antsmarch, cp98 and 3 others
-
6
MSW Applications Fall 2021
in Social Workers Forum
Posted
I emailed and informed them that my circumstances have changed and I have to rescind from the program. You can also state your reason. I made mine brief and they were understanding.