A Small Raven
-
Posts
51 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Posts posted by A Small Raven
-
-
23 minutes ago, cactusflower said:
No, I think it's fairly common to hear back from waitlists last minute, as many people take their time trying to decide between offers. So, makes things stressful, but it really could go either way.
Yeah, it seems like a funny kind of cycle – the whole admissions process is almost kind of at a standstill/stalemate, because people are sitting on offers while hoping to potentially hear back from waitlists, but sitting on those offers is also what stalls waitlist movement in the first place. It's like admissions gridlock. ?
34 minutes ago, cactusflower said:I am having a hard time deciding what to prioritize, so I'll ask generally--is anyone currently in a PhD in English Lit who is a creative writer in any capacity who might be able to speak to what it's like to try to make room for creative work while in a critical program? Or, if anyone feels like they have knowledge about this in generally and is comfortable messaging me privately, I would love to get some advice. Teasing very different pros and cons has been difficult. On the one hand, having a lot less teaching would make more room for creative work. On the other hand, a creative dissertation sounds very appealing, even with more precarious funding.
Also, I can relate to this dilemma, because I also applied to a mix of creative and critical programs after getting my MA in creative writing. While I'm not actually currently in this predicament as I don't actually hold any offers (sitting at 11 rejections and 1 waitlist ?) I considered the possibility that I might be faced with this issue (deciding between a critical or creative program) quite a bit, and what I might do if presented with this scenario. Just the thought of having decide between the two stressed me out a lot, and it is no doubt a really tough decision. For me, my main deciding factors would have been 1. location (having lived somewhere I didn't particularly enjoy before, this factor makes a big impact on my own personal happiness) 2. how engaging the community is (do they have clubs/organizations you can join, things to encourage you to be active in the graduate community) and 3. how attentive/helpful the faculty is (which you would generally get a sense of from contacting them).
If you need someone to kind of talk your thoughts out with on this one, I totally understand your dilemma, so please feel free to PM me!
-
Do we think it's a good or bad sign that I'm STILL waiting to hear back from a waitlist? ???
-
I did my MA in Creative Writing at Durham. While I can't speak specifically to the nature of how difficult the Literature program was (being as I was in Creative Writing,) I found the writing program to be exceedingly easy. Nevertheless, if you're thinking largely about student experience, there's a lot to consider when comparing these two schools, primarily due to their locations. When I applied to grad school, Durham honestly wasn't my first choice. But I absolutely fell in love with Durham while I was there, and had a fantastic student experience there – the town is small, but there's loads of good bars and restaurants about town, as well as some good shops. It's also just a quick 15 minute train ride to Newcastle if you want to do any kind of city shopping etc. I really enjoyed the postgrad social scene there.
One of the biggest differences between these two schools will be the social structure – Durham has a college system, whereas I believe Glasgow doesn't have a college system (I think only Cambridge, Oxford and Durham have college systems - think of them like Hogwarts houses). What college have you been admitted to? I was in Van Mildert, and made a good number of friends within the postgrad dorm, but also spent a lot of time over at Ustinov (the all post-grad college). My college was a bit far from the center of town (20 minute walk or so), but I still very much enjoyed it, and had a lovely walk along the river any time I needed to go into town.
I don't have a ton of experience/knowledge about Glasgow, however I did live in Edinburgh for six months after I finished my MA at Durham, and I ventured over to Glasgow maybe twice. Obviously, Glasgow is a bigger city compared to Durham being a small town. However, and while this may sound silly, something you should really take into consideration is the WEATHER. I found Durham's climate to be extremely agreeable – mild winters with a little snow to make it feel festive, a beautiful spring and autumn, and nice warm summers. It was much sunnier than I expected it to be. When I moved up to Scotland, people warned me to be prepared for the climate, and I shrugged them off, thinking it couldn't be all that much different from Durham, seeing as it's only about 1.5 hours north by train. In the end, the climate in Scotland is one of the major reasons I ended up leaving and moving back to the states. It is entirely different to Durham – the sky is gray most of the time, and it's often raining and windy. You do occasionally get a nice day here and there, but don't expect the summers to be warm...you will rarely, if ever, be able to wear shorts. So while it might sound like something ridiculous to factor into your decision, if you are AT ALL prone to a bout of seasonal depression here and there, the climate will make a monumental difference.
I've been living back in the states for a few years now, and I still miss Durham every single day. If you have any more questions about Durham, please don't hesitate to PM me!
-
4 hours ago, F22910 said:
Okay, so the April 15th deadline is typically fixed. I wasn’t aware of that, so thank you for confirming that for me. Also, according to my understanding, once a decision has been finalized to one school you can’t revoke it and accept a spot off the waitlist from another school. So then, please let me know if I’m missing something here because I don’t understand then, if say a current acceptance rejects their offer right on April 15th, to whom does that spot go if everyone’s finalized their decisions by April 15th? Do people end up gambling if they really want the waitlist school and give up their acceptance and just wait to hear back...?
I feel stupid for asking this... but am genuinely curious haha
I think I can answer that question! The spot probably ends up going to someone like me – who his hanging on 11 rejections, and 1 waitlist. ?
- F22910 and Hard times!
-
2
-
On 3/10/2022 at 3:19 PM, CoffeeLovingQueer said:
And has it been radio silence for the University at Albany?
Yeah as far as I know, absolutely nothing from Albany yet. They're the last one I'm waiting to hear back from.
-
Did anyone get an acceptance from Brandeis? There isn't a single one posted on the results board. I'm on their waitlist, and have been rejected by every other program I applied to. ?
-
I'm "high" on the waitlist for Brandeis, and have been rejected by every other program I applied to. ooooohh the anxiety!
-
1 hour ago, postmodern said:
I'm older1 and looking to change careers, and knew this was a long shot, just because of my relative weaknesses2 as an applicant, even before I really understood how selective the programs were. So yes I'm excited (because there's always a chance!) but trying to think of it like I've applied for fellowships -- it would be incredible to win but I'm not really losing anything because it wasn't mine to lose. Plus I know I'd be in better shape next time if I don't get in anywhere and decide to go through this again. So that's what my brain's telling me. The rest of me is looking at the spreadsheet I built based on reporting times averaged over the last five years and ranking programs by expected response.
1 Presumably older, I don't know. Maybe the rest of you guys are all ancient too.
2 Like how I overuse footnotesI feel like age is all over the place when it comes to doctoral programs. I'm 27 (oh god, 28 in a few weeks. Hello to the ominous approach of 30) and that feels old to me to be starting a PhD program, but I also know that this might just be my irrational psycho brain being, well...irrational. Because it's completely normal to start a PhD at any age, quite frankly. If anything, I feel like it would probably help my case more if I spent a couple years getting some kind of teaching experience before I applied, because my current work experience isn't all that relevant. But I guess we'll see how things turn out this round.
Mind you, I got my MA in the UK a few years ago, and even then I was one of the oldest Master's students around because of how the UK educational system is structured, so maybe that mentality has stuck with me, and that's why I feel old going into this.
-
37 minutes ago, forgottenworks said:
YES same. It feels like the terrifying quiet before the storm...
That's EXACTLY what it is. I check the results page about a dozen times a day, and my email about 10x that
-
14 hours ago, forgottenworks said:
Hope everyone is holding up okay during this crazy time! First-time PhD applicant here, I have one more app to submit and ten done...and then the agony of waiting. Does anyone have insight into how commonly programs conduct interviews? I've seen only one program actually say on their website whether they interview applicants (UT Austin, and they don't), and evidence on these here forums that past applicants have interviewed at UCR and UCI.
Welcome to the club! ? As far as I know, most programs don't conduct interviews, although there are a handful that do. NYU announced that they would be conducting interviews this year, though I don't know if they mention that on their website. It's new as of this year, and they announced it in an online info session in the fall.
You could look in the results section for school response records from recent years, and see if anyone posted interview invitations from where you're applying to.
-
50 minutes ago, theonewiththepies said:
This is helpful and eases some of my worries- I guess the waiting out is getting to me a bit. ?
Unfortunately yeah, you'll probably be waiting another 4-8 weeks to hear back from everyone. BC just sent me my first rejection yesterday, but they were also the first to get back to me last year, and it was about a month before I started to hear back from anyone else.
It is, unfortunately, an insufferably torturous period of agonized waiting that we must endure. Last year it absolutely demolished my mental health, and I'm sure it won't be any different this year. But we're all in this together, so just remember that you're not alone.
-
Anyone else already starting to get antsy waiting to hear back? ?
-
On 12/29/2021 at 5:07 PM, VicLitGuy said:
Does anyone have experience -- either as a current/previous student or someone who is applying now -- with these Boston area PhD programs: Harvard, Brandeis, Tufts, BU, Boston College. I'm looking for more information about them and if anyone feels comfortable posting or PMing me that would be a great help.
Specifically looking to know what the professor/student relationships are like, how accessible the faculty are, what the general vibe of the programs are, etc. Stuff you might not find on a website. Thanks!
So I'm applying to a few of these programs this cycle (Brandeis, BU, and BC). Of the dozen schools I'm applying to this year, I found BU's faculty to be some of the most accessible. The interim department chair even offered to do a zoom call with me for a little personal Q&A. Of course I mostly asked questions specific to my own research interests, but perhaps they'll be relevant to you – I asked about weaknesses in the program, and she did mention that the department is currently in a stage of transition – various poetry faculty are retiring, and they don't have strong Native American literary scholarship within the department, though they are hoping to bring some on board. They do, however, have pretty strong scholarship in transnational literature.
I also found BC and Brandeis faculty to be very responsive and friendly! When I reached out, they replied with long, thorough answers instead of just something short and generic (I received short generic answers from faculty at other schools, which makes the longer more personal responses stand out so much more). While that sort of thing might just come down to the specific faculty member you reach out to, for me, it reflected well on the department and made me more eager to apply. BC was one of the schools I applied to last year and was unfortunately rejected from, but...hopefully things work out better this time around! I Know BC does heavily lean towards Irish literary scholarship, so I'm not sure how much they distribute their admissions between Irish lit students and others on a year to year basis. I know they accepted a couple Irish lit students last year, so maybe they'll accept other research interests over that this year, to even things out. That's just my ungrounded theory though.
The Brandeis professor I spoke to emphasized that since they are such a small school, they have to be selective about the research areas they choose to develop scholarship in – he mentioned that American and British Romanticism are strong fields within their department. He also mentioned that they are acutely aware of how competitive and challenging the academic job market is, so they help prepare their students to become strong candidates for alt-academic jobs as well.
A note on Tufts – I looked at their program, and while it seems like a great school, I ultimately decided not to apply because it wasn't a good fit for my research interests – the department seemed particularly sparse on any kind of poetic scholarship.
Hope this helps! They all seem like decent programs to me, though they have their own strengths and weaknesses and specialties. Best of luck!
-
Officially submitted all 12 applications! I hope everyone else's apps are going well!
-
15 hours ago, zetasp said:
Hi all! I'm applying for the 2022 cycle as well with a solid 11 schools. I applied to some MAs and some PhDs a few years ago (2019 cycle), worked on an MA, and now I'm back to it. As a kind of second-timer, I can try to offer any advice!
Oh good you're applying to 11! Here I thought I was maybe being psycho overkill applying to 12, glad I'm not crazy ??
-
2 hours ago, thoreaulymodern said:
Hello all! Second cycle applicant as well, just digging up Grad Cafe as I get ready to submit my first round of apps this Monday (?). I'm currently in a fully-funded MA program after the 2019 cycle.
I saw an early, early response asking about what we changed for this second go at PhD apps. My writing sample is completely new (like, I literally wrote it from scratch at the urging of my LoR writer because she said I needed a more complex 'base' text to do close readings of), and I re-wrote both my statement of purpose and personal statement. I think they're stronger now- I name my interests right out the gate and have a clearer picture, theoretically, of where I want to go. that I hope is articulated there. My LoR writers also seem stronger this time around because they just know me better (faculty advisor, associate prof I've taken two classes with, and a full prof who I've done a few Zoom meetings with in the hopes he can emphasize theoretical expertise).
Good luck to you all!
This is also my 2nd cycle, and I had a similar complete turnover of my entire application. Completely rewrote my statement and tried to make it a little more tangibly focused, as it was a bit too theoretical before. I narrowed it down to specific eras and mentioned several authors I was going to focus on. Have a new LoR writer, although two of my recommenders are dragging their feet a bit with submitting, and that's making me extremely on edge, especially with the first deadline just days away. Also gave my writing sample a serious face lift.
I've submitted most of my apps, just have three to go! Granted, I left all the tougher, more complicated apps for last. That "optional" question on the Yale app (personal experiences, interests, or perspectives that you can bring to the Yale community) will plague me right up until submission day.
Anyway, best of luck to everyone! I hope we all get into our dream programs
-
Hey guys - this is a pretty basic question, but I feel like it might make a difference with what I'm doing in my apps – is there preferred formatting for the first page of the critical writing sample? Obviously it should have a title page, but do I need to put my name with 'writing sample for so and so application' on there?
I'm using a couple chapters from my master's dissertation, so I know I need to include a brief paragraph providing some kind of context for that on the title page. But what about a table of contents? It will likely just be two, maybe three chapters.
Thanks in advance!
-
Hi GradCafe friends -
So I've been living over on the English Lit side of the forum, because I applied to all English and Creative Writing PhD programs this cycle. It's my first PhD admissions cycle and was rejected everywhere, so I'm gearing up to apply again for next year. In addition to applying to English PhD programs, I'm also strongly considering applying to Art History PhD programs for next year.
While this might seem an odd combination of programs to apply to, the research that I want to conduct can essentially fall into either field - I'm interested in researching creative practices of artists and writers, with specific focus on dream studies and utilization of the unconscious. Thus, I'd likely be primarily focusing on surrealism (but if anyone else has commentary of other periods, artists, or movements I should look into, please let me know!)
I'm wondering if anyone has any experience or thoughts on applying for Art History PhD programs without having a particularly strong Art History background? My BA is in English, although I did minor in art and have a few undergraduate art history courses and a study abroad art business course under my belt as well. My MA is in Creative Writing. My MA research focused on the research I want to dive deeper into as described above, except it was focused on literary analysis instead of art.
Do I stand a chance getting into Art History programs even though my background is primarily in another field?
I'd appreciate any thoughts or advice, thanks!
-
4 minutes ago, Lighthouse Lana said:
RIGHT?! I asked when we might expect decisions and they said this week, but I'm sitting here at the end of the week and I'm not so sure...
Seriouslyyyyy like what is the hold up people? Pretty positive we're not getting those answers this week, but this is just getting crazy!
-
What's the protocol on emailing to ask if there's been any movement on the waitlist? The waitlist email I received (one month ago) was very kind and encouraging, they said they were extremely interested in my application and encouraged me to check back in before accepting a position anywhere else.
Sooo... it's ok to give them a nudge and be like "heyyyyyyy do you want me yet?" right? ?
-
-
2 minutes ago, kirbs005 said:
This is what I did, and from the feedback I got from my letter writers, it made sense the way I had it written. In theory, if you've framed your research and questions well, the committee should have an excellent idea of how good of a fit you are before you get to your paragraph telling them that. And with the limited space, I prioritized telling them about myself/framing my research over telling them about their department.
I also made sure to include my teaching experiences and why I wanted to do the PhD, Explaining why I want to be a professor. I have moved back and forth from academia, so it felt necessary to explain it. Tangentially, I did not do anything on top of the job I am currently working, but it's a corporate trainer job, so I am writing curriculum and teaching, which lends itself to the application process well.
But that's just my two cents, and I'm sitting at 2 rejections and a waitlist, with one pending.
That's something I probably could have done more - explain WHY I want to do a PhD and become a professor. I don't think I really touched upon that much at all in my SOP.
If my job was more relevant to academia, then I might not feel the need to bulk up my application more. But I'm a marketing director for a small business, and while I do a lot of content output and management, podcast producing, and even historical research and article editing etc., I feel that it doesn't necessarily have a direct line of relevance to academia.
I'm sorry you're in a tough spot too this cycle - I hope you get good news soon!
-
Hello my fellow literary geniuses -
So, things aren't looking too good for me this cycle unfortunately. (@cassidyaxx I am totally feeling your pain right now) I'm basically starting to prepare for having to apply again next cycle, and I wanted to get a few tips from you guys for next time around.
For my SOP - the majority of it was spent explaining my research interests and some of the questions I was looking to answer through my research, etc. because it's a very unusual area of focus. I saved the last couple paragraphs for explaining why I thought the school was a good fit for me. What's your thoughts on this format? Did you guys do something similar - discuss your research interests and then save why the school was a good fit for last OR did you talk about why the school was a good fit throughout the progression of your entire SOP?
Also, by the time next cycle comes around, I will have been out of academia for a few years. I'm lucky enough to have a very secure job to hold me over, but I'm just wondering what action I should take to try and strengthen my application in other ways for next year? While I'd like to get an adjunct teaching position or something, that's obviously almost impossible in this job market right now. I'm of course submitting to lots of contests and lit journals to try and get a publication or two under my belt. But what else should I be doing? Should I try to volunteer as a reader at a lit journal? I was thinking about taking a couple online classes over the next year in my research area, just to show that I'm still really engaged in it. I feel like I'm at a slight disadvantage, because I did my MA overseas, and was not given the opportunity to be a TA or anything during it, as I know most grad students do while acquiring their master's, so my resume is lacking in that.
Finally, if anyone knows of any departments or programs that happen to dip their toe into the cross section between lit and psychoanalysis, dream studies, etc. please let me know! Definitely going to apply to more schools next cycle, but it's difficult to find programs that specialize in my research interests.
-
1 hour ago, freehandsnake said:
hello! I'm a longtime lurker on here and just made this account to hopefully gain some courage to post some questions here later on.. but I saw your post and wanted to say that UNC has at least sent out one acceptance (it was me!) I posted on the results a week ago but it was kind of buried. Either way, I have no idea if all acceptances/waitlists have been sent out yet:( but, with the fact that I was notified last week, I hope they send the rest out soon... the waiting game is horrible. I hope you hear some good news soon!!
Congratulations on your acceptance!! If you don't mind me asking, what's your area of focus?
I did see that sole acceptance post on the results page, but I thought english and comparative literature were two separate programs, as they are at many schools. However after doing more digging, it appears they're one and the same at UNC. Ooooohhh boy this makes my anxiety spike even more!! It's not looking good for me fam. ?
2022 Applicants
in Literature, and Rhetoric and Composition
Posted
Unfortunately no, not a peep from them since last month. You're quite right – I am in absolute purgatory, and check my email approximately every four minutes. I assume they're probably in a similar situation to everyone else – I suspect their offer holders have not responded. It's honestly extremely frustrating.