historyprincess Posted February 5 Posted February 5 8 minutes ago, historianmusicologist118 said: GOT MY ACCEPTANCE NOTIF FROM BROWN! Hugeeee congratulations!!!!!!
meanwhilelife81a Posted February 5 Posted February 5 3 minutes ago, anhistorian said: Congratulations! Did you have an interview? May I ask what your subfield is? Yes I did! Late december… my subfield is Modern Germany/Holocaust and Genocide Studies CheckYesJules 1
AB2024 Posted February 5 Posted February 5 20 minutes ago, historianmusicologist118 said: GOT MY ACCEPTANCE NOTIF FROM BROWN! YAYYYYY!! Congratulations!
meanwhilelife81a Posted February 5 Posted February 5 7 minutes ago, AB2024 said: YAYYYYY!! Congratulations! Thank you! This is so unexpected as Northwestern and Chicago rejected me quite bluntly lol
obk90 Posted February 5 Posted February 5 19 minutes ago, historianmusicologist118 said: Thank you! This is so unexpected as Northwestern and Chicago rejected me quite bluntly lol Congrats!! And yes, the process can be pretty arbitrary.
Nervienellie Posted February 5 Posted February 5 congratulations everyone! Anyone here claiming the yale acceptance? Have all of them gone out do you think?
obk90 Posted February 5 Posted February 5 1 hour ago, Aishaaa said: I'm not sure about the current situation at Johns Hopkins, but I can share my experience with NYU. Last year, I applied to that and they announced acceptances and rejections in early February. After a radio silence, I received an acceptance in APRIL, but unfortunately, it did not come with funding. So, it really depends Thanks! And I'm sorry you were put through that. NYU really shouldn't be making unfunded offers. AB2024 1
obk90 Posted February 5 Posted February 5 48 minutes ago, historianmusicologist118 said: Yes I did! Late december… my subfield is Modern Germany/Holocaust and Genocide Studies Oh nice! Omer Bartov is a legend. historyprincess 1
ndoco2024 Posted February 6 Posted February 6 I wish schools would send rejections out first tbh, or at least at the same time as acceptances go out historyprincess, AB2024 and HistoryBuff1250 3
OHSP Posted February 6 Posted February 6 (edited) 3 hours ago, Aishaaa said: I'm not sure about the current situation at Johns Hopkins, but I can share my experience with NYU. Last year, I applied to that and they announced acceptances and rejections in early February. After a radio silence, I received an acceptance in APRIL, but unfortunately, it did not come with funding. So, it really depends That is very strange... are you talking about the PhD programme? NYU history has never accepted students without funding except for the MA. I am a graduate and had some insight into the admissions process last year. Just for anywhere who is on here and considering attending NYU, it is important to know that the NYU graduate school of arts and sciences offers the exact same package (a MacCracken Fellowship) to all students: https://as.nyu.edu/departments/hebrewjudaic/graduate/resources-for-current-students/phd-financial-aid.html. Edited February 6 by OHSP
meanwhilelife81a Posted February 6 Posted February 6 4 hours ago, obk90 said: Oh nice! Omer Bartov is a legend. Yes! He informed me that this is the last year he will take an advisee and I have been a fan of his for a long time. So it all feels surreal:)
Aishaaa Posted February 6 Posted February 6 15 hours ago, OHSP said: That is very strange... are you talking about the PhD programme? NYU history has never accepted students without funding except for the MA. I am a graduate and had some insight into the admissions process last year. Just for anywhere who is on here and considering attending NYU, it is important to know that the NYU graduate school of arts and sciences offers the exact same package (a MacCracken Fellowship) to all students: https://as.nyu.edu/departments/hebrewjudaic/graduate/resources-for-current-students/phd-financial-aid.html. Yes, I applied to the Ph.D. program, and then in April, they accepted me as an MA student without funding.
beee Posted February 6 Posted February 6 is anyone else here’s subfield gender & queer history (particularly in the US)? and have you heard anything yet?
meanwhilelife81a Posted February 6 Posted February 6 (edited) Congrats to all the Columbia admits! (I didn’t apply) and best of luck to those who applied to UW-Madison tomorrow! (They’re releasing all results) Edited February 6 by historianmusicologist118
obk90 Posted February 6 Posted February 6 Well, looks like it's a no from Columbia (looking at past years, it doesn't appear they have a waitlist). meanwhilelife81a 1
confusedmedievalist Posted February 6 Posted February 6 OOO we're playing my favorite game called "others have gotten acceptances and rejections, and my portal is still empty." I'm not too anxious because I have options, but can anyone explain to me why this happens? It just seems like a really strange thing for most official emails to go out at once, and then a few trickle in a few days later.
ndoco2024 Posted February 6 Posted February 6 5 minutes ago, confusedmedievalist said: OOO we're playing my favorite game called "others have gotten acceptances and rejections, and my portal is still empty." I'm not too anxious because I have options, but can anyone explain to me why this happens? It just seems like a really strange thing for most official emails to go out at once, and then a few trickle in a few days later. Same here! I am just confused about the whole thing. I am assuming they're rejections but why wait? Is it weird to email my POI to inquire about when to expect to hear back from them? We spoke back in October and I have seen acceptances from the program but have not heard back. I honestly just want to know if I got rejected or put on a waitlist or something confusedmedievalist 1
meanwhilelife81a Posted February 6 Posted February 6 Damn I guess UW-Madison is releasing rejections first….
obk90 Posted February 6 Posted February 6 23 hours ago, ndoco2024 said: I wish schools would send rejections out first tbh, or at least at the same time as acceptances go out If you applied to Wisconsin, you might have just gotten your wish
ndoco2024 Posted February 6 Posted February 6 1 minute ago, obk90 said: If you applied to Wisconsin, you might have just gotten your wish LOL
obk90 Posted February 6 Posted February 6 So with a rejection from Wisconsin, a de facto rejection from Columbia, and a likely rejection from Johns Hopkins, I am down to three programs. I probably should have applied to many more. I received conflicting advice on that question.
modernhist123 Posted February 6 Posted February 6 (edited) 9 minutes ago, obk90 said: So with a rejection from Wisconsin, a de facto rejection from Columbia, and a likely rejection from Johns Hopkins, I am down to three programs. I probably should have applied to many more. I received conflicting advice on that question. Maybe this is just my first rodeo, but this year seems particularly hard, I gasp just looking at the qualifications and achievements some history rejections have. Let’s get through this, and remember rejections are just redirections !! :))) Edited February 7 by modernhist123 confusedmedievalist 1
obk90 Posted February 7 Posted February 7 5 minutes ago, modernhist123 said: Maybe this is just my first rodeo, but this year seems particularly hard, I gasp just looking at the qualifications and achievements some history rejections have. Let’s get through this, and remember rejections are just redirections !! :))) I could be wrong, but I think the people who resentfully list all their accomplishments in their rejection posts might have inadvertently revealed a toxic personality in their application statements. modernhist123, meanwhilelife81a, the_geographer and 2 others 4 1
meanwhilelife81a Posted February 7 Posted February 7 24 minutes ago, obk90 said: I could be wrong, but I think the people who resentfully list all their accomplishments in their rejection posts might have inadvertently revealed a toxic personality in their application statements. That’s what one of my mentors told me to be careful about in the SOP. But good thing I’m raised in a culture where you should always show up with a sense of humility and willingness to learn.
Recommended Posts