Welcome to the GradCafe
Hello! Welcome to The GradCafe Forums.You're welcome to look around the forums and view posts. However, like most online communities you must register before you can create your own posts. This is a simple, free process that requires minimal information. Benefits of membership:
- Participate in discussions
- Subscribe to topics and forums to get automatic updates
- Search forums
- Removes some advertisements (including this one!)
You're right in your argument also, but I think we're both making different point about how the numbers affect the decisions. You're thinking mainly in terms of strong applicants, for which your argument might be right. But I'm speaking in a more generalised sense. In any case it won't hurt for people to post this information. Anyway, how many places have you applied too? Where are you from? Any feedback yet? I'm waiting on UWalerloo and SFU. You could hit me up @ firstname.lastname@example.org and we all could lament the suspense together, maybe even create a whatsapp group for aspirants, to keep each other updated. I'm a bit paranoid about posting in public forums and I'm sure most will be hesitant to post certain informations here too. Don't want anything negatively affecting my chances.
Sharing your research profile actually does tell a lot. If you're familiar with the admission process you'll know this. For research programs, students are often assigned to a supervisor based on your research interest. For example, if theres no professor conducting research in your area of interest or there aren't any openings for research in that area, you're almost rejected by default. (my friend was rejected for this, and in the admission status section one person said he was rejected for this in Waterloo some time in February) Professors are given the profiles of competitive students within their area of interest, and they have to pick students from the pool. So if there are a lot of people applying for your area, the competition is more. If for example you're the only applicant within your area of interest, and you meet all requirements and your profile is the only one forwarded to a certain professor, if he has opening in his group, you're selected by default. So like I said, you aren't really competing against all applicants, just those with same interest as you. Based on observations, majority of applicants are in for machine learning. So likely the most competitive.
What is the source of this information? This wait is killing. Guys you should post more information on your profile so we can help each other out to know the competition we're facing. For example, the total number of applicants isn't what's important. What's important is the number of applicants compe So guys post your research area and if you've had prior contact with a potential supervisor. MINE: Research area: Distributed Systems. Contact with faculty: Yes. Messaged a few, but received no guarantees.