Jump to content

Ella16

Members
  • Posts

    74
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Reputation Activity

  1. Upvote
    Ella16 got a reaction from kb6 in International Development Programs   
    Do well on the GRE and you'll be fine 
  2. Upvote
    Ella16 got a reaction from secondtimegrad in The 'Am I competitive' thread - READ ME BEFORE POSTING   
    I agree with your assessment that the GPA and GRE is quite bad and will hurt your chances. You generally need either one or the other to compensate OR amazing work experience that is several years removed from undergrad. Three years is not enough to be considered far removed and I think you'll have a very hard time getting into the top programs with aid. If aid isn't an issue and you can write a super compelling sop you may have a shot.
    Id recommend you study super super hard for the GRE and get those scores as high as possible and focus on your sop. Otherwise I'd be prepared for having to work for a couple more years before applying so that those undergrad grades don't blow your chances. 
  3. Upvote
    Ella16 got a reaction from freakaleke in International Development Programs   
    Do well on the GRE and you'll be fine 
  4. Upvote
    Ella16 got a reaction from MKPolicy in The 'Am I competitive' thread - READ ME BEFORE POSTING   
    can't really comment on the experience part but I do think that the fact that you are far removed from your undegrad and that you already completed a grad degree with a good GPA should attenuate the weight placed on your undergrad grades. That said you have a strong econ background and a really low quant score... You have plenty of time, I think it would definetly be worth it to study up on quant, do a bunch of timed practice problems/full length tests and get that score over 160. 
  5. Upvote
    Ella16 got a reaction from Bhu_It in Keep A Word Drop A Word   
    fake news!
  6. Upvote
    Ella16 got a reaction from kb6 in Stuck in dilemma (international student admitted to CIPA at $20k/year)   
    Revolutionary, I think you need to figure out what you prioritize, moving away from Pakistan no matter what you have to do or getting into policy even though it might take longer and mean you wont get a job abroad. As others have mentioned policy is not the type of career that will enable you to easily get job sponsorships abroad, especially not in the US at this point in time. 
    IOs are really the best option for internationals because of how hard it is to get a visa, but again those jobs don't grow on trees and with only one year experiece you will be competing with all of your classmates and people from other top degrees who have more and better experience than you. Simply having a Cornell degree wont make you a shoe in. It's not even amongst the top top top policy degrees in the states... I think you might be overestimating it a bit cause it's an Ivy (not saying that it's bad, there are just bigger names out there for this). 
    It seems like your heart is really set on Cornell and ultimately you're looking for people to justify your decision, as you hace noticed by now very few of us agree. However, there is no one path to success. Having 3-4 years of experience, great volunteering, 5 languages and whatever else people say you need to succeed won't guarantee you get a dream policy job in an amazing place and that you'll be happy. Although I agree that this degree right now is a big risk and seems financially irresponsible sometimes you gotta take the leap. If you do make the decision to go, make sure that you're going with your eyes wide open and that you are prepared for a scenario in which you don't get a visa in the US or elsewhere, don't get into a Phd of your choice (which i agree you should never do just for the heck of it) and will have to move back to Pakistan anyway. 
  7. Upvote
    Ella16 reacted to ExponentialDecay in Stuck in dilemma (international student admitted to CIPA at $20k/year)   
    @Revolutionary
    Policy is not a specialization. That's like saying you want to specialize in engineering. As regards interdisciplinarity, sure, most policy people have an interdisciplinary skillset - but that is not the same as having an interdisciplinary focus. Until you grow to the heights of Jim Kim or Noam Chomsky and can permit yourself to pontificate on whatever you damn well please, regardless of what they call you doctor for, you need to have a niche in order to get work. A narrow one. A niche in policy is something like innovation policy, or productivity analysis, or aquaculture in west africa. 
    I know some people who went the MPA - PhD route to stay in the country (which is unfortunately a necessary reality when you graduate from a middling MPA program and have no work authorization), among a broader circle of people who do so with whatever degree. None of them are at good programs, and none of them are getting academic jobs. Barring a strong undergraduate record (at a known university) or extensive work experience, the MPA isn't really a good gateway to a PhD. It maybe qualifies you for average polisci programs, random interdisciplinary programs, and public policy PhDs (for which academic jobs statistically do not exist). If you go that route, you need to realize that all you're doing is buying yourself more time to find a job.
    I can put you out of your misery: this field does not exist. Name any policy area, and you can spit and hit 10 specialists that have 3 citizenships, 5 languages, and star-studded resumes. If you want to work in an in-demand field, you're barking up the wrong tree. Try IT or finance. Nobody works here for the easy career progression or the piles of money; we do it either because we love it, or because we fell into it. What you can do to become an in-demand person is to 1) have a niche you are expert in (because you love it, because you're good at it, because you fell into it and stuck with it); 2) have a skill you do really well (statistics, writing, negotiation, etc); 3) be easy to work with (attitude, attention to detail, organization, good under pressure). 
    That said, I agree with the other dude. If this is an itch you need to scratch, go for it. I'm more or less convinced that your discontent can be explained by a combination of growing pains and a lack of experience with having real problems, and I personally give you low odds for success, but then I'd give anyone in your position, broadly, low odds for success and yet some people make it. Just do a conservative cost-benefit analysis before you go.
    I know nothing about Fulbright. Cap-exempt organizations are universities and NGOs associated with universities. As for your plan for getting a PhD and "settling" for an academic career, it makes you look completely clueless. The takeaway I want you to get from this post, if not this conversation overall, is that, if you are in the US on a visa, you ALWAYS have to plan for the possibility that you will be going home, because as long as you are on a visa, that possibility is always there. The second takeaway is that, so far, the ideas you have for keeping that eventuality at bay are either unrealistic or have very low odds of success.
  8. Upvote
    Ella16 reacted to rising_star in Stuck in dilemma (international student admitted to CIPA at $20k/year)   
    If you really want to get out of Pakistan, why not apply for jobs in other countries (China, India, Europe, etc.)? That would solve your immediate problem and give you the work experience needed to get into a more prestigious program in the future. I wouldn't go to Cornell just for the name because the name isn't that well-known even within the US (there are the Ivy names everyone recognizes then the four that everyone forgets about and Cornell is in the latter group). 
  9. Upvote
    Ella16 got a reaction from ExponentialDecay in Stuck in dilemma (international student admitted to CIPA at $20k/year)   
    Revolutionary, I think you need to figure out what you prioritize, moving away from Pakistan no matter what you have to do or getting into policy even though it might take longer and mean you wont get a job abroad. As others have mentioned policy is not the type of career that will enable you to easily get job sponsorships abroad, especially not in the US at this point in time. 
    IOs are really the best option for internationals because of how hard it is to get a visa, but again those jobs don't grow on trees and with only one year experiece you will be competing with all of your classmates and people from other top degrees who have more and better experience than you. Simply having a Cornell degree wont make you a shoe in. It's not even amongst the top top top policy degrees in the states... I think you might be overestimating it a bit cause it's an Ivy (not saying that it's bad, there are just bigger names out there for this). 
    It seems like your heart is really set on Cornell and ultimately you're looking for people to justify your decision, as you hace noticed by now very few of us agree. However, there is no one path to success. Having 3-4 years of experience, great volunteering, 5 languages and whatever else people say you need to succeed won't guarantee you get a dream policy job in an amazing place and that you'll be happy. Although I agree that this degree right now is a big risk and seems financially irresponsible sometimes you gotta take the leap. If you do make the decision to go, make sure that you're going with your eyes wide open and that you are prepared for a scenario in which you don't get a visa in the US or elsewhere, don't get into a Phd of your choice (which i agree you should never do just for the heck of it) and will have to move back to Pakistan anyway. 
  10. Upvote
    Ella16 got a reaction from PolicyStud in Stuck in dilemma (international student admitted to CIPA at $20k/year)   
    Revolutionary, I think you need to figure out what you prioritize, moving away from Pakistan no matter what you have to do or getting into policy even though it might take longer and mean you wont get a job abroad. As others have mentioned policy is not the type of career that will enable you to easily get job sponsorships abroad, especially not in the US at this point in time. 
    IOs are really the best option for internationals because of how hard it is to get a visa, but again those jobs don't grow on trees and with only one year experiece you will be competing with all of your classmates and people from other top degrees who have more and better experience than you. Simply having a Cornell degree wont make you a shoe in. It's not even amongst the top top top policy degrees in the states... I think you might be overestimating it a bit cause it's an Ivy (not saying that it's bad, there are just bigger names out there for this). 
    It seems like your heart is really set on Cornell and ultimately you're looking for people to justify your decision, as you hace noticed by now very few of us agree. However, there is no one path to success. Having 3-4 years of experience, great volunteering, 5 languages and whatever else people say you need to succeed won't guarantee you get a dream policy job in an amazing place and that you'll be happy. Although I agree that this degree right now is a big risk and seems financially irresponsible sometimes you gotta take the leap. If you do make the decision to go, make sure that you're going with your eyes wide open and that you are prepared for a scenario in which you don't get a visa in the US or elsewhere, don't get into a Phd of your choice (which i agree you should never do just for the heck of it) and will have to move back to Pakistan anyway. 
  11. Upvote
    Ella16 got a reaction from Revolutionary in Stuck in dilemma (international student admitted to CIPA at $20k/year)   
    Revolutionary, I think you need to figure out what you prioritize, moving away from Pakistan no matter what you have to do or getting into policy even though it might take longer and mean you wont get a job abroad. As others have mentioned policy is not the type of career that will enable you to easily get job sponsorships abroad, especially not in the US at this point in time. 
    IOs are really the best option for internationals because of how hard it is to get a visa, but again those jobs don't grow on trees and with only one year experiece you will be competing with all of your classmates and people from other top degrees who have more and better experience than you. Simply having a Cornell degree wont make you a shoe in. It's not even amongst the top top top policy degrees in the states... I think you might be overestimating it a bit cause it's an Ivy (not saying that it's bad, there are just bigger names out there for this). 
    It seems like your heart is really set on Cornell and ultimately you're looking for people to justify your decision, as you hace noticed by now very few of us agree. However, there is no one path to success. Having 3-4 years of experience, great volunteering, 5 languages and whatever else people say you need to succeed won't guarantee you get a dream policy job in an amazing place and that you'll be happy. Although I agree that this degree right now is a big risk and seems financially irresponsible sometimes you gotta take the leap. If you do make the decision to go, make sure that you're going with your eyes wide open and that you are prepared for a scenario in which you don't get a visa in the US or elsewhere, don't get into a Phd of your choice (which i agree you should never do just for the heck of it) and will have to move back to Pakistan anyway. 
  12. Upvote
  13. Upvote
    Ella16 got a reaction from Thanapoomped in Lee Kuan Yew School (LKY School), National University of Singapore (NUS)   
    I'm sorry I won't be meeting you lovely people in july, I'm sure we will all end up exactly where we belong in the end. I wish you all the best!  
  14. Upvote
    Ella16 got a reaction from Theo20 in Lee Kuan Yew School (LKY School), National University of Singapore (NUS)   
    I'm sorry I won't be meeting you lovely people in july, I'm sure we will all end up exactly where we belong in the end. I wish you all the best!  
  15. Upvote
    Ella16 got a reaction from Ndahi in Lee Kuan Yew School (LKY School), National University of Singapore (NUS)   
    I'm sorry I won't be meeting you lovely people in july, I'm sure we will all end up exactly where we belong in the end. I wish you all the best!  
  16. Upvote
    Ella16 got a reaction from Amir Shehzad in Lee Kuan Yew School (LKY School), National University of Singapore (NUS)   
    I'm sorry I won't be meeting you lovely people in july, I'm sure we will all end up exactly where we belong in the end. I wish you all the best!  
  17. Upvote
    Ella16 reacted to 2017 Applicant in Venting Thread- Vent about anything.   
    This is a kind of selfish perspective. Of course no one likes a braggart (though it's pretty early in the application season to conclude these people are "never" coming onto the site again and are just here to brag). But at the same time, no one has an obligation to tell you any personal information about themselves or give you proof that they've actually been accepted.
    The posters you are talking about probably just want to share their excitement with a lot of people. If your reaction to that is "that's my spot," "I don't believe you," or "how does that information help me" then maybe those threads aren't a place you actually want to hang out.
  18. Upvote
    Ella16 reacted to KhalifehA in Yale Jackson 2017   
    Glad to hear that!
    I got a call last week from the Fulbright scholarship program confirming my enrollment at Yale Jackson. Best phone call EVER!
    So I guess I'll see you in August @cbx2v !!
  19. Upvote
    Ella16 reacted to demogurl in HELP! Georgetown, NYU, or Columbia   
    What did you end up choosing?
  20. Upvote
    Ella16 reacted to anmanya in Lee Kuan Yew School (LKY School), National University of Singapore (NUS)   
    Congrats @Ella16. That's wonderful! 
  21. Upvote
    Ella16 reacted to Jughead in Lee Kuan Yew School (LKY School), National University of Singapore (NUS)   
    Congratulations, @Ella16. Great News.
    Is there an MPA group formed on FB or any other social Media that I can join ?
     
  22. Upvote
    Ella16 reacted to Etch in Lee Kuan Yew School (LKY School), National University of Singapore (NUS)   
    Congrats Ella16... Miracles still happen... Enjoy, dear
  23. Upvote
    Ella16 reacted to Amir Shehzad in Lee Kuan Yew School (LKY School), National University of Singapore (NUS)   
    @Ella16 Wow its a great news. Congrats!!
  24. Upvote
    Ella16 got a reaction from Nazaninn in Lee Kuan Yew School (LKY School), National University of Singapore (NUS)   
    @Diesek no, I had emailed then a couple of days back about deferring and was still waiting to hear back when they called me
  25. Upvote
    Ella16 reacted to Theo20 in Lee Kuan Yew School (LKY School), National University of Singapore (NUS)   
    Congratulation, @Ella16! I wish you accept the offer so we can meet on August! For those who are still waiting, I hope Ella's story can be a comfort for you
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

This website uses cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website. See our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use