phdapplicant321 Posted March 13, 2022 Posted March 13, 2022 On 3/12/2022 at 9:40 PM, gagne said: Hi, I’m a bit of a lurker here who applied to MFAs this cycle but do want to go on to do a PhD in the future and so have been lurking here. I’m curious about the prevalence of rejected from PhD accepted to MA. Is there a reason why programs do this ? As someone with a BA and then an unrelated MS Education, a little lost on this practice. Expand Hey! I am just finishing up my MFA in poetry and going into an English PhD. Do you mean rejected from (English) PhDs and accepted to MFAs, or MAs in English?
gagne Posted March 13, 2022 Posted March 13, 2022 On 3/13/2022 at 12:06 AM, phdapplicant321 said: Hey! I am just finishing up my MFA in poetry and going into an English PhD. Do you mean rejected from (English) PhDs and accepted to MFAs, or MAs in English? Expand Yes, that exact pattern. I'm less familiar with MA admissions and so wondering if this admission choice of "rejected from PhD, accepted to MA" is a funding choice on schools' parts
mostlygoo Posted March 13, 2022 Posted March 13, 2022 On 3/13/2022 at 4:48 AM, gagne said: Yes, that exact pattern. I'm less familiar with MA admissions and so wondering if this admission choice of "rejected from PhD, accepted to MA" is a funding choice on schools' parts Expand Seems to very much be a funding issue. MAs are partially funded at best, so I think the MA program ends up helping to fund the PhD program. No idea how many PhD applicants are rejected outright vs. redirected to MA programs -- and it's a box you can check on some program applications but not others, to be considered -- but I imagine the schools expect a much lower yield (% matriculated vs. accepted) for the MA program because of the funding challenges, so they can afford to offer more of these spots. (I was offered MA admission at Northeastern and CMU, and I think those may have been the only two programs where I checked the box to be considered -- mostly because it didn't require a separate statement or anything else.) gagne 1
forgottenworks Posted March 13, 2022 Posted March 13, 2022 If anyone is waitlisted for the literature PhD program at UN Reno, I just turned down my offer so hopefully there will be movement happening. Also, if anyone has intel on UC Davis's waitlist, I would love to hear! I'll probably reach out to them this week to see if they have any new info, as I'm just waiting on them before committing to UCI.
mirror_ Posted March 14, 2022 Posted March 14, 2022 On 3/9/2022 at 6:48 PM, Cordelipup said: Thank you so much for sharing! Would you mind also sharing which track you were in? Expand I was in the Literature & Culture track! Cordelipup 1
A Small Raven Posted March 14, 2022 Posted March 14, 2022 On 3/10/2022 at 8:19 PM, CoffeeLovingQueer said: And has it been radio silence for the University at Albany? Expand Yeah as far as I know, absolutely nothing from Albany yet. They're the last one I'm waiting to hear back from.
libramoon Posted March 14, 2022 Posted March 14, 2022 (edited) Hi all! Hope everyone's doing well. I was waitlisted at Duke back in January and I received an acceptance this morning. Anyone else admitted to the Duke English program? Edited March 14, 2022 by libramoon plainblacktights, katerinas, portaldisplay65 and 4 others 7
katerinas Posted March 14, 2022 Posted March 14, 2022 Is anyone else still waiting to hear from Penn? I saw the flood of rejections posted last week and a handful of acceptances a few weeks before, but it is still radio silence on my end and I'm not sure how to interpret it. I want to be hopeful, but what are the odds they are just waiting to reject me in the next wave? Congrats to everyone who has recently posted acceptances, though! You all are killing it! plainblacktights 1
libramoon Posted March 14, 2022 Posted March 14, 2022 On 3/14/2022 at 6:04 PM, katerinas said: Is anyone else still waiting to hear from Penn? I saw the flood of rejections posted last week and a handful of acceptances a few weeks before, but it is still radio silence on my end and I'm not sure how to interpret it. I want to be hopeful, but what are the odds they are just waiting to reject me in the next wave? Congrats to everyone who has recently posted acceptances, though! You all are killing it! Expand Hi! I applied to Penn's Africana program, not English, but if it helps, I've also been waiting on news from Penn since my interview on 2/10. I haven't seen any decisions on the forum for Africana, either. Last week I emailed the dept's grad coordinator who said that acceptances would come out either last week (nothing, but she did say they were on spring break) or this week. Hopefully English and Africana are on similar timelines! plainblacktights and katerinas 2
OpenBook Posted March 14, 2022 Posted March 14, 2022 Someone in the African-American Lit subfield just turned down Stanford for UCLA, so our waitlist may move.
F22910 Posted March 15, 2022 Posted March 15, 2022 Anyone turning down Rutgers? And if so, do you mind also sharing what your subfield is?
heterotopia Posted March 15, 2022 Posted March 15, 2022 On 3/15/2022 at 4:25 AM, F22910 said: Anyone turning down Rutgers? And if so, do you mind also sharing what your subfield is? Expand Hi, postcolonialist here. Turned down Rutgers two days ago. F22910 1
forgottenworks Posted March 15, 2022 Posted March 15, 2022 Anyone else still waiting to hear from UC Riverside? I'm presuming rejection at this point but closure would be nice.
thunderkee Posted March 15, 2022 Posted March 15, 2022 I just received a second rejection email from them (one was a note from the English secretary last week, the next was from the dean of Graduate Studies today), so we can share if you want? Gallows humor. plainblacktights and forgottenworks 2
thecat00 Posted March 16, 2022 Posted March 16, 2022 Hey all, I have four schools left to hear from, of which I've seen some results posted for each (either an acceptance, rejection, or a question about when the school will give its results). Any ideas about these scenarios and what it could mean? -- 1. Acceptances and waitlists posted from a program (with no rejections posted) that I'm waiting to hear from? 2. Rejections posted from a program (with no acceptances or waitlists posted) that I'm waiting to hear from? When would be the time for me to email these programs? I don't want to jinx anything by emailing. Any thoughts here? I would like to know soon, if at all, about what the outcomes will be.
phdapplicant321 Posted March 16, 2022 Posted March 16, 2022 What's the etiquette on declining offers? Are you expected to say why you are declining, where you are going... And should you inform faculty who have taken the time to speak to you? miniqueerthingy, forgottenworks, katerinas and 3 others 4 2
sadevilminion Posted March 16, 2022 Posted March 16, 2022 On 3/16/2022 at 7:10 PM, phdapplicant321 said: What's the etiquette on declining offers? Are you expected to say why you are declining, where you are going... And should you inform faculty who have taken the time to speak to you? Expand I emailed explaining that I was worried the stipend wouldn’t cover the cost of living, because that’s a big part of it for me. I didn’t mention other acceptances, although I’m sure they know that’s a part of it. Honestly I don’t think we owe them any explanation. phdapplicant321 1
sadevilminion Posted March 16, 2022 Posted March 16, 2022 Oof, I came here to say I’m so mad after reading the Boulder waitlist who said they only admitted TWO people this cycle. I was initially iffy about applying there in the first place, but now I know I waisted time and money on their dumb app. forgottenworks, katerinas, DavidFosterWallaby and 1 other 4
illcounsel Posted March 17, 2022 Posted March 17, 2022 Accepted off the waitlist at UBC! thursdaysnext, Cordelipup, Mumasatus and 1 other 4
thursdaysnext Posted March 17, 2022 Posted March 17, 2022 On 3/17/2022 at 12:50 AM, illcounsel said: Accepted off the waitlist at UBC! Expand Congratulations!!! ? How is it stacking up compared with your other offers?
katerinas Posted March 17, 2022 Posted March 17, 2022 What are y'all's opinions on reaching out to a program you still haven't heard from to check your status? I don't want to like... urge along my rejection if they are somehow still considering me, lol. But at the same time I have til April 14 to consider the MA programs I was accepted to and I only have one PhD still floating around out there.
OperaGhost Posted March 17, 2022 Posted March 17, 2022 On 3/17/2022 at 3:00 PM, katerinas said: What are y'all's opinions on reaching out to a program you still haven't heard from to check your status? I don't want to like... urge along my rejection if they are somehow still considering me, lol. But at the same time I have til April 14 to consider the MA programs I was accepted to and I only have one PhD still floating around out there. Expand Idk how others feel, but I'd personally say to go for it. I think most schools have a decent sense of where you stand in mid-march (as in whether you're in the "maybe" or "reject" category), so I don't think it would influence their decision katerinas 1
katerinas Posted March 17, 2022 Posted March 17, 2022 On 3/17/2022 at 3:31 PM, OperaGhost said: Idk how others feel, but I'd personally say to go for it. I think most schools have a decent sense of where you stand in mid-march (as in whether you're in the "maybe" or "reject" category), so I don't think it would influence their decision Expand Perfect. This response gave me the confidence to reach out! At least if it's a rejection I can be put out of the misery of waiting! plainblacktights and OperaGhost 2
F22910 Posted March 18, 2022 Posted March 18, 2022 On 3/15/2022 at 5:12 AM, heterotopia said: Hi, postcolonialist here. Turned down Rutgers two days ago. Expand Thanks for sharing that! I’m not a postcolonialist, so I don’t know if my chances of admissions have gotten any higher. But nevertheless thank you!
katerinas Posted March 18, 2022 Posted March 18, 2022 On 3/17/2022 at 3:57 PM, katerinas said: Perfect. This response gave me the confidence to reach out! At least if it's a rejection I can be put out of the misery of waiting! Expand Update on my own post... it was indeed a rejection. Sigh. That was my last hope for a PhD this cycle, so I guess I'm down to considering my masters acceptances now. What does everyone think? Is taking out loans for a masters worth it, or should I just take the year off and apply for PhDs again in the fall? I'd be looking at like ~$30k to accept one of the masters places I was offered. Hard times! and OperaGhost 2
Recommended Posts