Casorati
Members
Content Count
36 
Joined

Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Blogs
Everything posted by Casorati

Any credence given to internships/work experiences?
Casorati replied to discreature's topic in Mathematics and Statistics
Internships do not matter much unless you produce highquality papers, which is rare for undergraduate students. Your ability to do mathematical proof is the most important so I would take proofbased courses in mathematics or statistics. 
Can I get into a decent Stats PhD program?
Casorati replied to Recklessreader's topic in Mathematics and Statistics
How does Indian GPA translate into US/Canadian ones? If your 74% is equivalent to an A or above and you do well in real analysis/measure theory, you may have a shot at schools in the 3050 range such as Florida State/UConn/Ohio State and tie2 schools in Canada such as Simon Fraser/Western Ontario. From my experience, the subject test is pretty useless unless you aim for Stanford/Chicago/Wharton so I wouldn't take it. 
Mid Tier Statistics program(MS), how best to improve app
Casorati replied to Xos5000's topic in Mathematics and Statistics
If you retake these prerequisite courses and get good grades in them, I think you have a chance at midtier master's programs. The general GRE test is mostly used as a filter so you should be fine as long as your score in the Quantitative section is above the 80th percentile. Beyond calculus and linear algebra, the subject test also covers basic real analysis, complex analysis and abstract algebra and I doubt MS programs care about the test. Without a strong pure math background it is impossible to do well so I wouldn't take the subject test. 
Profile Evaluation  MS Statistics
Casorati replied to fujigala's topic in Mathematics and Statistics
Master's admissions are much less competitive than PhD's since you pay for the degree. With your profile, if you can get your GRE Q to 166+, I think you should be competitive for the top 10s. I would definitely apply to top schools like Harvard, Berkeley, Chicago and Stanford as well as add some safer options in the top 20s. 
If you haven't taken any proofbased courses, I don't think it's a good idea to take gradlevel probability courses. I would start from basic real analysis courses. Ideally you need two courses in real analysis covering material such as metric space/norm, completeness of metric space, hÃ¶lder's inequality/Minkowski inequality(this can be further extended to other spaces such as Lp space and probability space) , basic topology, continuity/uniform continuity in metric space and Riemann integration. It would be better if you had exposure to Lebesgue integration before taking gradlevel probability courses since probability space is a special general measure space and understanding Lebesgue measure definitely helps.

Profile Evaluation for Fall 20201 Biostat PhD/MS
Casorati replied to tukey's topic in Mathematics and Statistics
Since you are from a top school that is known for grade deflation, your grades should make the cutoff for the schools you listed. In order to have a better chance, I would take real analysis this fall since it is going to be helpful even if you do applied research. If you scored an A or above, I think this would be a positive sign for admissions committee. I would apply straightly to PhD programs and add a few MS programs. 
Profile Evaluation For Stats Phd 2021 fall
Casorati replied to nauhark's topic in Mathematics and Statistics
I wouldn't recommend you take a gap year because nobody knows what the situation will be like in 2022. Since you haven't taken abstract algebra and complex analysis, it would be very timeconsuming to prepare for the test. Unless you are deadset on getting into Stanford, I wouldn't recommend taking the math GRE. You have excellent math grades from a good school, so you should be competitive at the top 15 programs in US News if you can secure strong letters. I think some schools accept fall grades and you could submit them if you do well, which I think will help your case. As for program selection, aside from the top 15 schools, You could also add a few larger and lower ranked programs such as Penn State, Purdue and UIUC just to be on the safe side. Given the current political climate in the US, international student visas are harder to come by so I would also consider applying to a few top Canadian programs such as Toronto/UBC/Waterloo/McGill. 
I wouldn't worry much about your low grades in general ed courses since they are less important. You have good math grades from a top school and if you can improve your GRE Q to 166+, you should be able to get into some top 20s. You may even have a shot at schools like Michigan/CMU/Duke. Admissions for biostatistics/OR is somewhat less competitive than statistics and I can see you get into really good biostat/OR programs. For example, Northwestern and Cornell have a very good OR program and I think you have good chances at those. Meanwhile, you could also consider top schools in Canada like Toronto and UBC.

Profile Evaluation  PhD Statistics (Do I have a shot?)
Casorati replied to Hedy's topic in Mathematics and Statistics
Your mathematics and statistics background is lacking and I am guessing your undergrad institution is not super famous. With that said, I don't think you have a shot at the schools you listed. If I were you, I would first do a master's in statistics and take real analysis and mathematical statistics. If you do well in your master's, you probably have a shot at schools at the level of UGA/Michigan State. 
Thank you for everyone's response. I have no prior experience in machine learning but I am open to research areas I've not yet considered. It appears that ARWU places Waterloo ahead of UBC and McGill while QS statistics ranking places UBC and McGill ahead of Waterloo. Which ranking is a better proxy of the academic reputation?

Although I did causal inference research during my master's, I'm also open to other research areas. I have found areas such as functional data analysis and spatial data interesting. McGill's Biostatistics department seems to be pretty small and focused and I prefer larger departments with more research areas.

Seems that many people vote for UNC. Is it worth it to turn down a funded offer and accept UNC, which does not guarantee funding?

I am fortunate to have been admitted to the Statistics PhD program at UBC, Waterloo and Biostatistics PhD program at McGill, UNC (unfunded) and Florida and I am having a hard time making a decision, so I would like to seek out advice from you guys. It seems that the academic placements at UBC and UNC are very good, and McGill is a better research fit as they have a group of people doing cuttingedge research in causal inference. Florida is relatively new but there are a few faculties I would like to work with. Waterloo has a large statistics department with a focus on applied side. Obviously UNC has the best reputation but I don't think it sensible to pay for the tuition and living cost for 5 years.

Fall 2020 Statistics Applicant Thread
Casorati replied to ENE1's topic in Mathematics and Statistics
Is anyone still waiting on UNC Biostatistics PhD? I emailed them on the 16th but still haven't received a reply. 
Fall 2020 Statistics Applicant Thread
Casorati replied to ENE1's topic in Mathematics and Statistics
I haven't heard anything yet but today I found that a new section 'NC Residency Checklist' was added to my portal. 
Fall 2020 Statistics Applicant Thread
Casorati replied to ENE1's topic in Mathematics and Statistics
I am also waiting on UNC Biostatistics. A few days ago they told me that all the remaining applications were on the waitlist. According to the result section, UNC probably hasn't sent out many rejections yet so there may be a large waitlist. I think the probability of getting off waitlist is low at this point. 
Undergrad Institution: One of UBC, Toronto, Waterloo Major(s): Math/Statistics Minor(s): GPA: High 80s, 90+ in math/stat courses Type of Student: International Asian Male GRE General Test: Q: 170 (96%) V: 153 (60%) W: 3.5 (39%) GRE Subject Test in Mathematics: 870 (89%) TOEFL Score: Waived Grad Institution: Same school Concentration: Statistics GPA: ~90 Programs Applying: Statistics/Biostatistics PhD Research Experience: Part time RA with an assistant professor during undergrad. Graduate RA resulting in a master's thesis. Both related to causal inference. Paper submitted to Statistics in Medicine. Awards/Honors/Recognitions: Nothing major. Pertinent Activities or Jobs: TA for undergrad statistics courses Letters of Recommendation: One from my master's supervisor (associate prof), one from a senior prof who I took grad math stat with. One from an assistant prof whom I did my undergraduate research with. Math/Statistics Grades: Calculus 13 (A+;A+;A+). First year Algebra (A+). Linear Algebra 12 (A+;A+). ODE I (A+). Intro to Prob (A+). Intro to Statistics (A+). Real Analysis I (A). Real Analysis II (A). Measure Theory I (A+). Abstract Algebra (B+). Complex Analysis (A+). Mathematical Statistics I (A+). Mathematical Statistics  Casella & Berger (A+). Graduate Statistical Inference (A+). Applied Probability (A+). Stochastic Processes (A+). Applied Linear Models (A). GLM (A). Time Series (A). Experimental Design I (A+). Experimental Design II (A+). Survival Analysis (A). Missing Data and Causal Inference (A+) Applying to Where: Biostatistics PhD: Pennsylvania  Rejected Michigan  Rejected UCLA  Rejected McGill  Accepted Minnesota  Rejected UNC  Waitlisted Florida  Pending Johns Hopkins  Rejected Berkeley  Rejected Statistics PhD: Wisconsin  Rejected Stanford  Rejected UBC  Accepted Penn State  Rejected UIUC  Rejected Toronto  Rejected Waterloo  Accepted Wharton  Rejected Some takeaways: The competition among international students has gotten very stiff in recent years. I got accepted into 3 Canadian schools I applied but got rejected across the board for US schools. I imagine that my Canadian background was looked upon favourably during admission at UBC/McGill/Waterloo. However, it appears that even for tie2 schools like Penn State/UIUC/UCLA, the bar for international students to get in is still very high. This may have something to do with the current political climate in the US as many schools are restricting the number of international students that can enroll. With that said, there are some very strong programs in Canada or even Europe that you can consider. These programs have strong faculty members consistently publishing in top journals as well as solid placements records. If you look at UBC, the placement data indicate that over half of their graduates ended up with a faculty position, which is better than some of the tie2 programs in the US. I encourage future applicants to look into Canadian schools as well. If you do well in these programs, you will be in a very good shape in academic market after graduation.

I am fortunate to have been admitted to UBC Statistics PhD and McGill Biostatistics PhD and I am having a hard time deciding between the two. So I would like to seek out advice from you guys. My goal is to attain a faculty position. It seems that 60% of graduates from UBC went into academia while McGill did not post their data. UBC has wider range of research than McGill but McGill is a better research fit as they have a group of people doing cuttingedge research in causal inference. Also, what tier of schools in the US would be comparable to the above two schools?

Fall 2020 Statistics Applicant Thread
Casorati replied to ENE1's topic in Mathematics and Statistics
For Michigan Biostatistics, I randomly checked the Wolverine portal yesterday and and there was a 'view decision' link. I clicked into it and it said 'A decision has been made. Your program of application will inform you of the decision.' However, I haven't received an email yet. Since I haven't received an interview, does it mean I am rejected? 
Fall 2020 Statistics Applicant Thread
Casorati replied to ENE1's topic in Mathematics and Statistics
Has anyone heard back from Michigan biostatistics? I saw some rejections posted. Did UIUC interview international students who study in North America? 
Fall 2020 Statistics Applicant Thread
Casorati replied to ENE1's topic in Mathematics and Statistics
Do you know any international student who got accepted or rejected? 
Fall 2020 Statistics Applicant Thread
Casorati replied to ENE1's topic in Mathematics and Statistics
Has any international student heard back from UNC biostatistics PhD? 
I have a friend who applied two years ago. He took many advanced math courses such as measure theory, functional analysis, graduate probability theory and did very well in them, but he had no statistics research experience. He applied to ~6 schools ranging from Chicago to UNC and ended up getting into nowhere.