I'm having a hard time deciding, too! I definitely feel like I'd be happy at either program and I'm also just grateful to have gotten in. The two programs I'm considering are both fully funded, but one is offering significantly more of a stipend. The one with the better financial package is ranked a little lower than the other one (although obviously these 'official' rankings are usually out of date and not the end all be all). I'm really excited about the faculty at both schools, but in terms of my main subfields, they have different strengths and weaknesses. I feel like I've exhausted the list of questions to ask current students and faculty, I've made pro/con lists, talked to one of my former professors, and I'm still torn. What else are you all doing to help you make decisions? Does anyone have any less obvious questions that they asked students or faculty that they found particularly illuminating?