In General, I can say that the acceptance rate of grads (to PhD programs from MA) is not as high as it might be for other programs. Mostly, this is bc the MA program is huge. However, NYC is one of the best places to do cinema research and immerse yourself in the independent cinema world. What I would also caution is that they do not actually take a ton of their own MAs straight into the PhD program upon MA completion. It's usually about 1 student. They do try to reserve spots for MA alums from previous years but it's not the gaurenteed spot that you might think it is. True, there isn't a ton of funding for MAs but there is some. You can reapply for funding after the first year and you might get some. Does this help?